As we have been reading Hamlet in class the same question
has been in my mind from the start. While reading I have gotten the impression
that Hamlet is an intelligent young man not to far off from a kid my age,
however, when we watched clips from the film he seems much older than that.
Although the director has a lot of freedom with the play, in both versions we
have watched the actors playing Hamlet were middle aged men. Like grey hair and
everything. This was interesting because in the play itself Hamlet seems so
much younger.
First of all Hamlet is trying to go back to school which to me indicates
that he is a young adult around nineteen or twenty. Claudius says to him while
holding court, “For your intent,/In going back to school in Wittenburg,/It is
most retrograde to our desire”(1. 2. 112-114). It is against Claudius’s and
Gertrude’s will for Hamlet to return to school in Wittenburg. If he is
returning to school it would be fitting that he is a young man. Which is why I
am confused with the actors chosen to play the role in the movies.
My
second reason to believe he is so young is that Hamlet is still working on his
relationship with his mother. He is very protective of her and still almost
argues with her as a young man may. He is not naïve however, he and his mother
seem to be still developing their relationship and an older middle aged man
would already have this figured out.
Lastly I
get the impression that Hamlets relationship with Ophelia further characterizes
him as a young man. Because her father is so involved with relationship it
seems that he treats her as a child making her seem young. They way he treats
her makes her seem young so in turn Hamlet seems young (assuming Hamlet is not
a pimp? But I don’t know.) . Polonius speaks to Ophelia about her relationship
with Hamlet and says “ ‘affection?’ Pooh, you speak like a green girl,/Unsifted
in such perilous circumstance./ Do you believe his ‘tenders,’ as you call
them?” (1. 3. 100-103). He calls her a “green girl” in other words an inexperienced
girl which denotes to naïve or young. The way that Polonius approaches Hamlet and Ophelia’s relationship
reminds me of how a protective father may look at his daughters first
boyfriend. This again makes it seem as if they are a young couple and Hamlet is
a young man.
I am
hoping as the play progresses my question will be answered. There is currently
a disconnect in the transition from the play to the movie which confuses my
perception of Hamlets character. I believe this is a highly debated question in
the play but as of now I am confused as to why he is portrayed as older in the
film version of the play.
No comments:
Post a Comment